/ Cocktails

Captain's Cutlass

Author: Jonden Jackson

Three ingredients: aged rum, fresh lime and brown sugar. It is a Daiquiri with brown sugar in place of syrup, and the swap changes everything — molasses in the sugar meets molasses in the rum, and the drink turns deeper and rounder than the classic.

Ingredients:
Method of Attack:
  1. Pour the rum into a cocktail shaker half-filled with cubed or cracked ice.
  2. Add the sugar and squeeze in the lime juice.
  3. Shake vigorously — harder and longer than feels necessary. The sugar needs to dissolve completely.
  4. Strain into a chilled cocktail glass and serve straight up.
About This Recipe:

A cutlass was the short, heavy, single-edged blade carried at sea — no finesse, no reach, built for close work on a crowded deck. This drink is the same idea. Three ingredients, no garnish, nothing to hide behind.

It is the oldest shape a rum drink takes. Sour, sweet, strong: British sailors were building it from lime and sugar long before anyone wrote a recipe down.

Why this rum:

With three ingredients, the rum is the drink. There is no cola, no cream, no mint to carry a weak spirit. Falconet Midnight is aged 8 to 15 years and carries the oak and dried fruit that brown sugar reaches for.

The sugar point matters here more than most places. You are adding a teaspoon of sweetness deliberately — if the rum has already been sweetened at the bottling line, you have no idea how much is actually in the glass. Bombarda carries no added sugar, no caramel colorant and no chill filtration, so what you add is what is there.

Battle Notes:

Shake until the tin is painfully cold. Undissolved brown sugar settles in the bottom of the glass and the last mouthful tastes like syrup.

For the classic version with simple syrup, see The Falcon Daiquiri. For the full picture, our guide to the best rum for a Daiquiri.